Executive recruitment process: What are CEOs looking for when they hire?

Although the hiring process for any employee will include certain steps and considerations, these elements are critically different when it comes to executive recruitment and hiring. Decision-makers within the C-suite must find candidates with skills that align with current management process but will also represent a good fit with current staff members. Any missteps with…

Although the hiring process for any employee will include certain steps and considerations, these elements are critically different when it comes to executive recruitment and hiring. Decision-makers within the C-suite must find candidates with skills that align with current management process but will also represent a good fit with current staff members.

Any missteps with executive recruitment and hiring could mean bringing someone on board that doesn’t have the right capabilities, and having to start the whole process over again when things don’t work out.

In order to avoid this expensive prospect and find the right candidate, there are certain things that CEOs look out for specifically during the recruitment process. As a candidate for an executive-level role, there are a few things to know that can help you pursue your next opportunity.

What traits do CEOs look for?: The basics

There are certain character traits that are must-haves for professionals seeking executive roles. No matter the recruitment team or industry in which the organisation operates, having and being able to demonstrate these traits will help put candidates on the short list:

  • Professionalism. Above all, candidates should be have a professional persona, from their clothing to the way in which they answer interview questions.

  • Confidence, especially in decision-making. CEOs will prioritise professionals that are sure of themselves. This is particularly important when it comes to their thinking and decision-making skills – candidates that appear indecisive or wishy washy are typically very quickly eliminated from recruitment considerations.

  • Motivation, and ability to self-monitor. It’s not enough to simply be bold and driven. Today’s CEOs are also looking to recruit those that are goal-oriented and able to push themselves on to the phase.

  • Flexibility and adaptability. The current business landscape is changing all the time – from the emergence of new technology, to changing industry regulations that businesses must adhere to. Recruiters seek candidates that can keep up with this type of fast-paced environment, and be flexible enough to accept changes while being adaptable in the way they shift toward new goals or needs.

Other traits, including those related to communication and personal skills, strong leadership and experience, are critically important as well. Candidates that are able to show their skills during interviews – such as having anecdotes ready about times in which certain skills enabled them to solve an issue or make improvements – will be highly valued.

Beyond the obvious: Skills and talent below surface-level

In addition to the above capabilities and character traits, CEOs also want to look deeper into candidates skills and talent.

Performing well under stress, for example, can help professionals stand out from other candidates. This is especially important as more recruitment leaders and CEOs create atypical interview processes. As opposed to a traditional sit-down, question-and-answer style interview, some hiring managers may ask that candidates deliver a mock presentation, or provide a 30-day business plan. Some interviewees also appreciate role-play exercises where candidates can demonstrate their skills in difficult situations. Being able to deliver on these expectations despite the high-stress situation well help show the CEO that particularly candidates are well-suited for an executive role.

It’s also key to have an understanding not only of the employer, but the industry in which the organisation operates in. This is true whether or not candidates have experience in that particular sector. It’s especially helpful to perform some due diligence and research the business, its industry and the challenges other companies might face in order to demonstrate a keen understanding of the company’s needs.

In addition, professionals that are proactive about executive-level opportunities – especially when the CEO and recruitment team is looking to hire from within – can make a particular impact on decision makers. Participating on more advanced projects or initiatives, and building one’s skills through higher education, mentorship or certification programmes can demonstrate potential candidates’ interest.

Finally, it can be especially helpful – and particularly attractive to the CEO and hiring manager – when candidates have a strong professional network. Including these connections as references on the resume is a good start. Experts also recommend following industry leaders on social media or subscribing to professional blogs as a way to digitally connect and grow one’s network.

CEOs and recruitment managers won’t want to waste their time on candidates that are just average. The hiring process for executive roles is typically much more involved than that for mid- or entry-level roles, but the time and effort can considerably pay off.

Check out our Insights blog to learn more.

Discover insights.

12.13.2023

Creating messages that cut through social media, news cycles and even the humble inbox has never been easy, but, with more noise across more channels, it’s become more important than ever to create messages that stand out and land with impact. Visual communications tools are gaining traction as a way of shaping messages that hit…

05.10.2023

Looking for greater choice in the contract options available to you? Having history and rapport with a specialist recruiter like Fraser Clapcott will open doors to opportunities you may have missed for yourself, that add value for both contractor and employer. In the current climate of uncertainty, a willingness and propensity for flexibility comes with…

05.04.2023

If you’ve been ruminating on changing-up your comms career, now may be the ideal time to talk with your trusted recruiter about making a move. Salt & Shein Director, Lucy Newcomb, sees significant scope for motivated communicators to broaden their career horizons, and make the job of their dreams a reality, in 2023. “A rapidly…

Discover insights.

12.13.2023

Visuals hit the mark in a fast-paced world

Creating messages that cut through social media, news cycles and even the humble inbox has never been easy, but, with more noise across more channels, it’s become more important than ever to create messages that stand out and land with impact. Visual communications tools are gaining traction as a way of shaping messages that hit…

05.10.2023

Rapport yields exceptional results for contractors

Looking for greater choice in the contract options available to you? Having history and rapport with a specialist recruiter like Fraser Clapcott will open doors to opportunities you may have missed for yourself, that add value for both contractor and employer. In the current climate of uncertainty, a willingness and propensity for flexibility comes with…

05.04.2023

Curious about the current state of play for communicators?

If you’ve been ruminating on changing-up your comms career, now may be the ideal time to talk with your trusted recruiter about making a move. Salt & Shein Director, Lucy Newcomb, sees significant scope for motivated communicators to broaden their career horizons, and make the job of their dreams a reality, in 2023. “A rapidly…

Salt & Shein
10.21.2022

How to Drive Value Using Digital Marketing

Digital marketing drives value – for those who keep pace Faster communication, lower costs, higher conversion – is there anything digital marketing can’t do? Its ability to drive value from every step of the marketing process is unprecedented, but maximising this value is a demanding exercise. We asked two specialists in this area to tell…

06.14.2022

Economic Challenges Threaten to Cloud the Focus on ESG

ESG is just one challenge on Government’s long list The government’s election promises around environmental, social and governance (ESG) issues were instrumental in its victory a few weeks ago, reflecting a mandate to treat climate change, gender equity and other ESG matters as essential. “Australian businesses know that action on climate change is good for…

05.31.2022

Addressing the skills shortage

Unlocking opportunities for families across Australia As a boutique executive search firm, we’ve seen up close the impact of Australia’s labour shortage as the pool of candidates continues to shrink, limiting the growth of careers and businesses – and hampering national productivity. With some 425,000 job vacancies across Australia, no wonder the OECD recommended that…

04.04.2022

Leadership: Why showing employee appreciation and care can go a long way

Everyone has to start from somewhere. Meaning you’ve probably held an entry-level position at one point or another, in which trying to impress the higher-ups in your company was a major part of your job.   This article will explore why employee appreciation and recognition are a vital part of holding a leadership role not…

03.18.2022

The future of recruiting includes ESG initiatives

Whether or not a company acknowledges how much their social, environmental and governance (ESG) decisions impact the world around them, candidates are taking notice. Most job seekers will pass over a company that is not taking steps to improve how they show up outside of their business metrics for an organisation that does.    This…

01.31.2022

Changes to the work environment in the new norm

People all over the world and especially in Australia have faced incredible challenges in the past two years. Those businesses that survived multiple shutdowns and policy changes are finding new ways to adjust as they enter the post-COVID work environment. As offices begin to reopen, enterprise leaders are not only deciding among the options of…

12.16.2021

Solving the skills shortage: Closed borders and adjusting expectations

With the revolving door of new COVID-19 regulations, variants, opened (then closed again) borders and an exodus of non-Australian workers, the workforce across the nation is facing a severe skills shortage.  Despite these challenges, there are solutions. The secret to overcoming this qualifications shortage lies in taking a proactive approach to hiring through policy changes…